Christmas, Hanukkah, Yule, Kwanzaa, Diwali (kind of), Boxing Day, and sometimes Ramadan

The other night I went to my friend Heather’s birthday dinner at a local sushi restaurant. She and I were a bit early so we had the opportunity to make mindless chit-chat before her other friends arrived.

Heather asked, “Do you take suggestions for posts on your blog?”
“Absolutely,” I replied.

Delighted, Heather launched into her idea for a post on holiday greetings. She works at a local organic store and has trouble knowing how to greet people during the “holiday season.” Heather noted how offensive it is to assume people are Christian by wishing them a “Merry Christmas,” so she opts for the more politically sensitive, “Season’s Greetings” or “Happy Holidays.” She believes people are insensitive to assume people are the same faith as them. I understand her point, but it didn’t take long for me to have a different position on this topic, and here it is.

People have too much time on their hands when they choose to be offended by a well-wishing comment. The emphasis is on the word choose. I believe that in most circumstances, we choose how we react and feel. Or at least, we choose how much weight we give it in our lives–the longevity of its significance within our existence. What are you really frustrated with? Because it’s probably not that person or their stereotypically mindless utterance of a holiday greeting.

Now, are there exceptions to my opinion? You bet. Someone who looks at a person whose faith is demonstrated in their clothing fashions (say, a Hasidic Jew for example) and still wishes them a Merry Christmas might be less sensitive than they should be. In that case–assuming the speaker is familiar with the connection between the dress and the religion–it would be best to go for a more neutral greeting out of respect. If I know what religion the person is, I do my best to acknowledge and honor their traditions. But I still believe that person has the right to wish another person joy in the name of their religion if it is said with kindness and mutual respect. And the receiver of the comment can decide to not find it offensive. I also believe that in the case of acquaintanceship and friendship, people have a responsibility to inform (not proselytize) their friends of any particularities their faith requires in regard to dietary and other restrictions when it is going to be relevant to an event (say, a holiday party). The same could be said of one who is a vegetarian or who has a food intolerance.

Any discriminatory speech (using derogatory slang like the n-word) is something at which one could be justifiably offended. In cases of race and ethnicity, those uses of slang relate to a long history of discrimination and abuse. Similarly one could argue that every individual religion too has had a history of abuse and discrimination. So I suppose some would argue that knowingly wishing a non-Christian “Merry Christmas” is derogatory because you are not acknowledging their faith. Knowingly ignoring someone’s religion or cultural history is definitely insensitive and can be down right offensive. No doubt. We should remember, too, that the person may be unaware that what s/he said is offensive (surprising but true), at which point perhaps a little information rather than reaction is in order.

But when it comes to social interaction involving strangers, I have a different perspective. And I would hope this would be the attitude in all circumstances, even among friends and neighbors.

I am not a practicing Christian, though I was raised in a faith under that umbrella of faiths. I myself ascribe to no faith–just a personal code of ethics and morals that I hope derive themselves from the best parts of all religions. I have had friends who practice Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Wicca, Asatru, Atheism, Reformed Mormonism, and Agnosticism. None of those friends, particularly the non-Christian minority ones, take offense at the well-wishing slogans of other faiths. As a matter of fact, most take it in the spirit it is meant: “I wish joy to you during this time of gift-giving, joy and gratitude, family-celebrations, and religious observations!” When a Christian says to me, “I will pray for [fill in my current problem here],” or “God bless you,” I take that as a compliment. They are not condemning my beliefs, but they are willing to take the time to talk to their god on my behalf because they wish me well. They are hoping good things will come to me, wishing their god will give me the love they believe I deserve. That is a very loving act in my opinion. I do not say, “If your god is Christian, I don’t want your prayers.” How rude. I say “Thank you.” Would anyone turn down prayers from another faith in their time of need? I doubt it. So why take offense at similar well-wishing during a season in which so many faiths hold celebrations? Of course there are those who are so “devoted” to their faith as to believe I am damned. Their “I will pray for you” usually has a condescending air to it. It annoys me. Certainly.  But why waste my time being angry at them? Instead I take a moment to pray for them, that they will learn compassion and tolerance. And then I move on. I would rather focus on the kind words coming my way.

I believe that we all relate to one another from our viewpoint. I also believe most of us try to be sensitive to people’s beliefs. So it is only natural that a Jew will say, “Happy Hanukkah,” and a Christian will say, “Merry Christmas,” and a Wiccan will say, “Blessed Yule,” and so on. They say it because that is what they know, that is who they are. They don’t say it with malice, with agenda, but rather with joy and a communal feeling of love. So why not say, “Happy Hanukkah to you!” to wish them a happy holiday? Or reply with your faith’s slogan and smile warmly? I’m sure that we can all reach across our differences this holiday season to recognize that when we reference our religions in our festive words, we are usually just offering up an opportunity to celebrate happy times together by connecting through the spirit of the times rather than the dogma of our religious differences.

6 thoughts on “Christmas, Hanukkah, Yule, Kwanzaa, Diwali (kind of), Boxing Day, and sometimes Ramadan

  1. Let me put some ashes in your stocking …

    I say “Merry Christmas” (except to a Hasid, or an obvious Muslim) not only because I am Christian, but because this is a Christian country. What does that mean, really? It means that the near-virgin territory white men discovered and began settling 5 centuries ago was overwhelmingly built – made into the settled land it is today – by (white) Christians. It was persons who self-identified as Christians who did all the hard work of forming the nation. That we have idiotically, collectively suicidally allowed tens of millions of non-Christians (and nonwhites) to take up residence in our homeland, and that we the descendants of the Christian settlers have too often needlessly (and sinfully) forsaken our ancient faith, does not change the essential (ontological?) status of America as a Christian nation. Thus, saying “Merry Christmas”, as I do in all but obviously non-Christian cases, is an expression both of conservative solidarity with one’s ancestors, as well as a recognition and implicit approval of the ethnocultural core of the US. It reminds all and sundry just who the hell this nation belongs to.

    Let me suggest you flush the PC down the sewer, and start demonstrating gratitude towards your forbears – instead of worrying about which pushy, hyper-sensitive, unwanted immigrant foreigner you might be offending.

    • Hi Leon, thank you for commenting.

      I feel gratitude to my forbears, but for different reasons than the ones you have. I am sure many value your sense of appreciation for the development of the United States. I however believe this country belongs to me. I was born here, have lived here my entire life, and I am not Christian. What I think is best about this wonderful place is the very freedom of people to worship as they please, without harm to others.

      On another note, as you mention the difference between “white” and “non-white” residents of this country…. Christian missionaries have traveled to many countries and ministered to and converted many “non-white” people to Christianity. I don’t imagine all these Christian faiths were wrong in trying to share their faith with others, no matter their race. Regardless, I couldn’t more disagree with you in every way. A person’s race does not change their value in my eyes.

      In thinking about the founding of many countries, I imagine it would be difficult to pinpoint the exact populations and religions of those who first settled the area. Also, early in its infancy America was sent convicts and people of numerous faiths. Unless there was a tally of each people’s beliefs I find it hard to verify that all who founded the USA were Christian. And of course, the Native Americans helped the first Pilgrims farm the land, guaranteeing their survival. What would this country be without these non-Christians? A great deal of our economic growth historically is thanks to the work of immigrants. And of course there is the fact America was founded exactly for the sake of worshiping freely of all faiths…. On another note, how would the Jefferson Bible figure into your particular heroic view of our forefathers?… I suggest you read “The People’s History of the United States” by Howard Zinn. You may find it interesting

      I appreciate your suggestions, but I don’t plan on flushing my PC behaviors down the toilet, as you put it, any time soon. These behaviors and motivations are not as much “politically correct” as they are morally and spiritually important to me. As one who was raised under the umbrella of the Christian faith, I believe in mutual tolerance and respect of all, even those with whom I disagree or those who don’t believe the same things as I do. I prefer to find common ground between faiths rather than condemn them for their differences. This is my way, and I plan to keep it. But best of luck to you in your approach.

      Best wishes to you this holiday season Leon.

  2. Leon – I hear what your sayin’ man! People just don’t think of the founding forebearers anymore! Every time I hear someone say “Merry Christmas” I get insulted because they stole half the stuff for that religion from my Pagan ancestors! I’d tell everyone what I’d like to do to those people, but being as this blog is called “Be Nice” I won’t (besides, we can’t practice sacrifice anymore, for some reason our religious freedoms were taken away!)

  3. I don’t know if any of you have seen this… just something to mentally munch on!

    The following quote is from Ben Stein (as seen in Ferris Buller’s Day Off):

    “I am a Jew, and every single one of my ancestors was Jewish. And it does not bother me even a little bit when people call those beautiful lit up, bejeweled trees, Christmas trees. I don’t feel threatened. I don’t feel discriminated against. That’s what they are, Christmas trees.

    It doesn’t bother me a bit when people say, ‘Merry Christmas’ to me. I don’t think they are slighting me or getting ready to put me in a ghetto. In fact, I kind of like it. It shows that we are all brothers and sisters celebrating this happy time of year. It doesn’t bother me at all that there is a manger scene on display at a key intersection near my beach house in Malibu . If people want a crèche, it’s just as fine with me as is the Menorah a few hundred yards away.

    I don’t like getting pushed around for being a Jew, and I don’t think Christians like getting pushed around for being Christians. I think people who believe in God are sick and tired of getting pushed around, period. I have no idea where the concept came from, that America is an explicitly atheist country. I can’t find it in the Constitution and I don’t like it being shoved down my throat.”


I want to hear your thoughts! Please share....

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s